Does Dumbledore love Harry?
Bethany
bethanymil79 at yahoo.com
Fri Feb 18 21:39:30 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 124842
Lupinlore:
> If nothing else, I think the way JKR has set up the story kind of
> obviates it, since she implies that there isn't any way for the
> Wizarding World to be destroyed (i.e. Voldy to win) without Harry
> going along with it. That is, it isn't a choice of Harry or the
> WW, since the story implies that Harry can only survive by saving
> the WW.
>
> That means, though, that DD could be faced with a truly hellish
> fate if he really loves Harry. Lose Harry and save the WW, or
> lose Harry and keep the WW. Either way he loses Harry.
Bethany again:
I guess I don't know what you mean by "Either way he loses Harry".
I mean, couldn't Harry defeat Voldemort without losing his life?
There's nothing in the prophecy that we know of "for sure" that says
if one dies the other has to as well. I'm more of the belief that
when/if Harry defeats Voldemort, he will lose the powers that he
shares with him. I don't think Harry has to necessarily turn to the
dark side to stay alive. But, if it is fated that way, then
Dumbledore will definitely be losing someone very dear to him, and
yes, someone he loves.
No one can convince me that Dumbledore does not love that kid.
Harry's strength, his sheer will to survive through all the
heartache he's been through - we all love him, how could Dumbledore
not? I especially see it in the end of book five when he speaks
with Harry so patiently after Harry is raging and throwing things in
his office. It's very apparent to me. But, as I said before, love
and sacrifice go hand in hand. In the end, love won't matter as
much as duty and the greater good...
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive