De-bunking Count Snape

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 125039


> > 
> > In Post 124996 Pippin wrote:
> > >snip< and *this* is why  the  Marauders hideout was behind a 
> > mirror...>snip<
> > 
> > Potioncat:
> > I missed that. The Marauders had a hideout behind a mirror? 
> I'd like  to go back and read it. Can you give the chapter?
> 
> 
> OOP ch 17 --(Sirius speaking)
> "There used to be a pretty roomy secret passageway behind that 
> big mirror on the fourth floor, you might have space to practice 
> jinxes in there--" 
> 
> "Fred and George told me it's blocked," said Harry, shaking his 
> head. "Caved in or something."
> 
> PoA ch 10 (Fred speaking)
> "Don't bother about with the one behind the mirror on the fourth 
> floor. We used it until last winter, but it's caved in--completely 
> blocked."
> 

Valky:
Yeah *that* hideout, where Peter Pettigrew spent year OOtP... 
because it's not really caved in, that's just a trick of the eye Tom 
Riddle Ginny conjured in year COS.... 

But I am not sure why that would point to Snape being a vampire?
Are you saying that Our Marauders *chose* a place that Sevvie would 
by impulse steer well clear of?
That kind of makes sense I suppose.
 
OTOH what about the foe glass, Pippin? Whose foe glass does he 
appear in? Crouch!Moody's? If that's the case it could also be 
explained as Sevvie was curious as to why he was Moody's foe, when 
they are supposedly on the same side. Or maybe he was keeping and 
eye on it so that he could avert "Moody"'s eye from it and avoid him 
seeing what might be truth about Snapes alignment in the foe glass..

I just might try to debunk Vampire!Snape, I am fence sitting at the 
moment... I don't think that Lupin is a veangeful type, he probably 
set the essay as a cute joke I'd say, but then again I could be 
convinced otherwise....

Valky