Dobby a Parallel to Kreacher?

M.Clifford Aisbelmon at hotmail.com
Fri Feb 25 12:46:59 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125170


Brodeur:
> I could not help but draw a connection between Dobby and Kreacher. 
> They both dislike there masters so much, that they are both 
> willing to go out of there way to help the opposing side. 
> In Dobby's case he came to warn 
> Harry about what was going to happen in his second year at 
> Hogwarts. In Kreacher's  case he 
> went and told Narcissa Malfoy about Sirius and his semi secrets.
> In both cases both House Elves broke some form of agreement with 
> there masters, 

Valky:
This fascinates me, also. Wasn't there supposed to be a kind of 
Magic Bind of Elves to the homes of their master's? Whatever it was 
it appears either to be weak, or weakened.

I wonder if the determination of Dobby to do right by Harry 
Potter "broke" it, or the eventual reward of freedom that Harry gave 
to Dobby in return?











More information about the HPforGrownups archive