Is Snape doomed?

Ehren clehrenet_81 at yahoo.com
Sat Feb 26 00:00:16 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 125210



Long time reader...first time poster, my apologies if this has 
already been covered.

I do beleive that Snape is on DD's side whatever his motives are for 
being there. However, is he the DE that has left Voldemort forever? 
If he is I just do not understand how he could be a spy as well.

If Snape was a double agent for DD during the first war (GF pg. 590-1 
us paperback) and can be presumed thats what he is doing now and 
wouldn't Voldemort know GF713 OoP591? I mean, when Quirrel had Voldy 
hiding underneath his turban in SS/PS, don't you think he would have 
known Snape had been warning Quirrel about where his "loyalties 
lie".  So if Voldemort knows: why is Snape still hanging out with 
Lucious?

So if Snape really is a spy, why hasn't Voldemort figured it out an 
AKed him already? Unless of course Snape really is not being a spy 
and he is the "one who has left us forever." If thats the case its 
obvious why he joined DD, to help bring Voldy down and for protection 
only DD can provide. 

For the beleivers that Snape is on the good side and whether or not 
Voldemort will kill him, what are your thoughts? I am very anxious 
for JKR to tell us Snape's role in the books!!!

Ehren- 
who is rereading all the books in anticipation of the HBP!










More information about the HPforGrownups archive