Where does it say that Molly is a pureblood fanatic???
horridporrid03
horridporrid03 at yahoo.com
Sun Feb 27 00:59:17 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 125261
>>Betsy:
>...I don't think there's much in canon to suggest exactly *what*
Molly's beliefs are, but there's a fair bit that hint she might not
be as liberal as her husband.<
>>vmonte:
>Sorry, you are wrong here. The reverse is true.<
<snip>
>It would be quite clear to the readers of the HP books if [Molly]
did not care for Hermione and Harry.<
<snip>
>>Valky:
>Hmm I don't think Betsy doubts Molly's feelings for Harry and
Hermione, (right Betsy?)<
<snip>
Betsy:
Right-ish, Valky. I do have *some* doubts as to Molly's feelings for
Hermione, based on how quickly Molly turned on Hermione in GoF.
Remember, Hermione had been developing a relationship with the
Weasley family since PS/SS. She had been a guest at Molly's home,
and Molly had met Hermione's parents at least once. Hermione was
more than just a name her son and daughter mentioned from time to
time.
Now honestly, would anybody meeting Hermione think, "got to lock up
my sons with *that* one around,"? And yet, Molly, after reading
*one* bad article by Rita Skeeter of all people (who is clearly
defined as a liar by the entire Weasley family at the beginning of
GoF), suddenly decides that Hermione is the kind of girl to chase
after boys based soley on their fame. Why on earth was Molly so
gullible? One explanation is that Molly really *doesn't* trust
Muggles or Muggle-borns. (Harry is *not* Muggle-born. And his
parents are war heros. Plus, he's got the adorable little orphan
factor going for him.)
If you add that to Ron's natural reaction to half-breeds (Lupin and
Hagrid) and Molly's own reaction to an unknown werewolf, I think
there's plenty of canon to suggest Molly is really not as liberal as
Arthur.
>>Betsy:
>I think the word "swarming" is pretty negative. But my book
(scholastic paperback) says "packed" which is much more benign. Does
the British version say "swarming" or did someone misquote somewhere
down the line?.<
>>Valky:
>Mine is a Bloomsbury edition and it says "packed" so it's likely a
misquote.<
Betsy:
Well, poo. I had a whole thesis building off the word "swarming". So
there goes my, Molly is completely bigoted against Muggles, argument
<g>. But I still think that there is some latent distrust of
anything not wizard in Molly, and at times of worry or stress it
comes to the forefront. So she's not Death Eater, and won't become
ESE, but she *is* old fashioned in her views - more so than Arthur.
Betsy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive