Marietta and Hermione (was JKR's Messages ) (was Re: Hermione In Trouble?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 120890


> Del replies:
People WERE willing to hear Harry out fully - it's Harry who wasn't
willing to talk. Seamus asked, Zacharias asked, but Harry refused to
talk. He demanded that they believe the fantastic and thoroughly
simplified version DD fed them.


Alla:

Ummm, what fantastic version? Simplified, yes, I am not sure I can 
call it fantastic - it was  still truth, just not as detailed one.

I think it simply was too traumatic for Harry to talk about the 
details.


Del:
 
There was NOTHING for people to hear out FULLY. People were FORCED to
take a decision based on a few unsupported and undetailed lines of
story. Forced by Harry. I can't blame them for going against Harry.
Honestly, if a teenager said tomorrow that he didn't kill another 
kid,it's the aliens who did it, and no he's not going to tell more, 
well,I wouldn't believe him either.


Alla:

I think name "Voldemort" should ring more bells for people in WW 
than story about aliens. They went through a horrible war with said 
wizard already, so if someone claims that Voldemort babck, and not 
just ANY teenager, but someone who even if unwillingly helped to 
vangush him, I'd say they should listen.

So, yes, I CAN blame them for going against Harry, but I understand 
the unwillingness to admit that someone who caused such terror is 
back.

And of course I blame Fudge most of all for not listening to 
dumbledore and Harry and influencing public accordingly.




Just my opinion,

Alla