Marietta and Hermione (was JKR's Messages ) (was Re: Hermione In Trouble?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 120914


Alla:
 I would like for her to come up with better plan 


Eggplant:
 
> Better Plan? What more do you want? Her plan prevented Harry from 
> being tortured into insanity or death and nobody except Umbridge 
got 
> hurt. A perfect outcome. It was a brilliant plan, certainly I 
can't 
> think of a better one and I doubt you can either.
>

Alla:

Actually I can think of quite a few better plans, but what I am 
asking if it is not too much to ask - please, do not misstate my 
arguments.

The other part of the sentence, which you snip said "IF 
circumstances will allow ". I was talking about the future, IF 
unfortunate need will arise.

I UNDERSTAND the stress Hermione had to do her quick thinking under 
and I do not fault her for that. I am GLAD that she saved Harry.

BUT under less stressful circumstances I am not sure I find hate to 
be the best weapon even in fight against evil.


It is a very good thing , IMO, that we keep arguing about Hermione's 
actions - I myself keep changing my mind on Marietta's thing after 
reading different arguments. Shades of gray could be a lot of fun to 
discuss.

I think I agree with those who said that Hermione's actions are 
appropriate at the time of war and not at the time of peace and 
Hermione WAS at war.

I may change my mind tomorrow again though. :o)


Alla