Marietta and Hermione (was JKR's Messages ) (was Re: Hermione In Trouble?)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 120941



Eggplant:
 
So you say. I keep hearing you and several other people say that, 
but I've not actually heard of one plan that was better, let 
alone "quite a few". Not one.

Alla:

Eggplant, I give up. Have you read my whole post or you just pick 
out one part to change the substance completely?

I AGREE with you in a sense that Hermione should not be faulted this 
time, because she was under tremendous stress, but if she was not, 
for whole list of better people to lead Umbrdige to, I refer you to 
Pippin's post.

Am I being THAT confusing? I hardly think that half an hour in the 
Forbidden Forest WITH Umbridge breathing down their necks is enough 
time to think about those people, Hermione demonstrated remarkably 
quick thinking as it is already, BUT on general theoretical 
principle, I think it is possible.



Alla