Snape's view (was Re: Harsh Morality)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 121077


Potioncat:
I think you are right.  I know many on this list think that it 
should be obvious to Snape that Harry isn't like that. But if you 
look at the times Snape sees Harry and if you look at the situations 
Harry gets into,  most of them confirm Snape's view.

Alla:

Not sure about many, but to me it is not that it should be obvious to 
Snape that Harry is not like that, but that Snape should try harder 
to see Harry for who he is and the fact that it is hard for him to do 
so is not sufficient excuse for Snape's behaviour TO ME.

Let me also raise my eyebrows in the question mark at your "if you 
look at situations Harry gets into, most of them confirm Snape's 
POV". :o)

First of all not all of them, some of them confirm such view ON THE 
SURFACE and Snape is not willing to look deeper (bad, bad Snape :o))

Second of all are you telling me that on every Potion lesson there is 
an altercation between those two? In other words, surely there are 
some quiet moments, when Snape can at least get a hint, that MAYBE 
Harry is not James.

Just my opinion,

Alla