Greatest Fear/greatest Hope

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 7 22:02:32 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 121397


Mizstorge wrote:

My greatest HOPE is that JKR isn't going to keep up with her bigotry 
about Slytherins. You know, the "Why do you keep going after the bad 
boys?" rant. Although she keeps comparing them to Nazis, anyone who's 
actually read about Nazi Germany knows not *all* Germans, and not 
even *all* Nazis, were murderous genocial maniacs. Maybe *most* 
Nazis, but certainly not *most* Germans. I truly hope *some* 
Slytherins will be ambitious enough to support their School, and 
perhaps the Ministry, because they realize in the Brave New World 
Voldemort supporters are going to be outcasts. I hope the Slytherins 
in general, maybe Draco and Pansy in particular, are going to to be 
the cavalry who come riding in to save the day and their House 
finally gets the recognition it deserves at Hogwarts.


Alla:

If you take a close look at pure-blood ideology, it sure looks very 
similar to fascism to me. As to Nazis, at the moment I am debating 
whether I should start ranting or not, but for now let me just say 
that any Nazi supporter is guilty of THAT - supporting ideology, 
which claimed that one race is better than others and willing to kill 
the people of different ethnicity.

Let me refer you to post 108672 about fascism-like ideology of Voldie 
and Co.

I will be the first one to say that Slytherins need help, but untill 
they get rid of "purebloods are better than everybody else mindset", 
they do NOT deserve ANY recognition in Hogwarts.

Just my opinion,

Alla







More information about the HPforGrownups archive