Sorting-Slytherins (wasRe: Greatest Fear/greatest Hope
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 7 22:28:59 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 121406
Potioncat:
So far there has been no firm JKR hint that Slytherins will be
anything other than the baddies.
There have been vague hints (or rather some of us have inferred
vague hints) that we may be surprised with some good Slytherins.
Alla:
Agreed
Potioncat:
What if, the hat sorts you according to ambition/cunning and being
of Pure blood, but not necessarily according to your pureblood
mindset? For expample, when I was in junior high (the year our
schools were integrated) if you put all the white students in one
room, a great many would have been pureblood racists. But not all
of us. And some of us would have been in the process of un-learning
years of training, although not all way there yet.
Alla:
Agreed again. And that is why we are awaiting the good Slytherins,
right? I do hope that they are not all lost causes, but do you see
Draco racing to save the Light? Do you have any doubt about HIS
mindset?
Potioncat: just for thought, not to start a raging debate.
Alla:
LOL!
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive