my greatest fear....

lavaluvn lavaluvn at yahoo.com
Sat Jan 8 08:23:52 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 121446


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
> 
> Carol :
> Yes. I think you've hit on what most of us fear, an unsatisfactory
> ending. I don't think for a moment that JKR would cheat us with 
an "it
> was all a dream" ending, but I am afraid that she'll have Harry 
doing
> something that violates the moral code she seems to be setting up
> here, specifically, I'm afraid that she'll have Harry murder 
Voldemort
> with an Unforgiveable Curse. (I don't care that Voldemort deserves 
it;
> I don't want Harry to be stained with the evil of his enemy's 
weapons.)
> 

Now Andromeda:
  I don't think you have to worry about that, exactly.  We (and 
Harry) already know that an Unforgivable Curse isn't going to kill 
Voldemort.  It can't, no doubt due to whatever spellwork it was that 
Voldemort had done to "never die".  No, I think Jo's hints that we 
need to understand why Voldemort survived his own powerful AK curse 
implies that Harry will need to find it out himself.  Maybe if Harry 
can undo the spell(s), Voldie will die of natural causes?  Lose his 
powers? Ok, maybe not, but I'm sure it will be more complex than 
just using an Unforgivable curse, which Jo has clearly 
labelled "unforgivable", or even just outright killing.  My personal 
belief is that Harry will defeat Voldemort and yet not end up a 
murderer.  How, I have no idea.  I have some faith in JK!

-Andromeda, free again from the clutches of Yahoomort







More information about the HPforGrownups archive