Harry's anger (was Re: Draco's anger.)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 122014


Pippin_999 Wrote:
 
Harry is feeling horribly guilty 
over the death of Sirius 

Eggplant:

Yes, and part of the blame can be put at Harry's feet, perhaps 2%, 
but Dumbledore and Snape should feel far more guilty, I'd put their 
responsibility well into the double digits.

Alla:

I can go even with assigning Harry let's say ... 10% of the blame 
(all numbers are relative of course), but surely no more than 
that. :o)

JMO.


Pippin:
 snip.

At some level he knows it's not rational 

Eggplant:
I think Harry's anger was very rational, even Dumbledore knew that.


Alla:

Eggplant, I absolutely agree. I never understood how Harry blaming 
Snape is irrational.

Now, it may very well turn out when we have all evidence presented 
that Harry was WRONG to blame Snape for the disaster(I am talking 
about Occlumency and Sirius death, both), but with the evidence we 
have NOW and especially what Harry has, I will say that Harry has 
PLENTY of RATIONAL BASIS to blame Snape.


Even if Harry has to go with the fact that he felt worse after the 
lessons, I'd say he is very rational to feel suspicious of Snape.


Besides, yes, Harry had been wrong many many times about Snape, I 
think that can be red herring too. I think it is a possibility that 
Harry may turn out to be right for once. 


Just my opinion,

Alla