Harry's anger (was Re: Draco's anger.)

[eggplant9998]

No: HPFGUIDX 122046


pippin_999" <foxmoth at q...> wrote:

I said Dumbledore did not excuse Snape and his Occlumency lessons and 
you then quoted some stuff from the book that in no way contradicted 
what I said.  

> Either Snape was wrong to stop the lessons, 
> in which case they can't have been making Harry weaker 

Agreed, if that turned out to be true then Snape was wrong to stop 
the lessons.

> OR the lessons were harmful, in which case
> it wouldn't have been wrong to stop them.
 
Agreed, if that turned out to be true then Snape was wrong for being 
a very crummy teacher of Occlumency. Either way he was wrong.
 
> But Harry doesn't think it through,
 
Harry thought it through very well and came up with the correct 
answer, or at least a very plausible answer; only time will tell if 
he was correct but I think he probably was.
 
>That's irrational, IMO.

Not IMO.

Eggplant