Favorite Snape Scenes - He's such a lovely professor, no really.

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 122201


Tonks here:
First Harry is a child. Normally he would never have been told all 
of the things that he knows about because he is a child and has no 
business in adult affairs.  It is only because he is the prophesy 
child that he is told anything.

Alla:

I think it is pretty big "because". :o)

Tonks:
Second Snape is a spy and this is 
not a game. This is serious and dangerous work that Snape is doing. 
Why should he let down his guard for some kid who will first blab to 
his friends and Snape knows who else!!!  Snape is not stupid you 
know. Even WE know that he will tell Ron and Hermione!! And even if 
he doesn't he will start acting differently toward Snape. There will 
not be the same amount of hatred in his eyes and someone will 
notice. 


Alla:

I am not asking you to agree with me that Snape may not be spying 
anymore, but I am asking you to pretend for a second that you 
agree. :o)

If we knew for sure that Snape did not go back to Voldemort, would 
you agree that Snape has NOT justification whatsoever for treating 
Harry like he does?

Personally, I think that even if he is spying,it is no 
justification, but since  his "spying duties" are often argued as an 
excuse, I wonder what do you think.


Thanks,

Alla