Favorite Snape Scenes - He's such a lovely professor, no really.

dumbledore11214 dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Mon Jan 17 22:41:36 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122210


Betsy:
Snape was right, of course. Harry's father did strut, and often.
James wasn't above hexing students in the halls either. And IIRC
this scene occurs when Harry is caught breaking school rules and
putting his own life in danger. Again.

I can see that Snape would be a bit jealous of the school's BMOC (big
man on campus). Most freaks and geeks are -- though that's only a
part of the tangle of emotions the bullied and picked-on feel towards
their tormentors.


Alla:

I must have missed  the scene in the books when Harry picked up on 
Snape. This is one of my strongest "want to slap Snape" moment. 
James is dead . Snape has NO right whatsoever to criticise him in 
front of Harry, regardless whether Snape was right or wrong, IMO

Vmonte responds:
All I have to say here is: SNAPE GROW UP ALREADY! SO WHAT IF YOU'RE 
A GEEK! GET OVER IT!


Alla: 

Oh, I would not count much on it, Vmonte. I don't think Snape ever 
managed to grow up as far as Harry and James are concerened.

He is so engrossed in his petty childhood vendettas that he does not 
realise that he won long time ago. James is dead. He is alive. Maybe 
it is time to stop tormenting James's son and get to know him for 
who he is. Sigh...

Just my opinion,

Alla











More information about the HPforGrownups archive