[HPforGrownups] Snape and Sirius related? Was: Re: Half blood prince etym...

[HP5Freak at aol.com]

No: HPFGUIDX 122248

In a message dated 1/17/2005 8:52:20 PM Central Standard Time, 
madettebeau at gmail.com writes:

> 
> 
> >Tonks:
> >
> >[slight snip] Mr. Black marries his son off to a pureblood within a
> month 
> >or 2 of the annulment/divorce and she gets PG right away.. and you 
> >end up with two boys about the same age, from the same father with 
> >different surnames. 
> >
> >It just might work.
> 

Amberlyn:

While I love this theory....(mostly because I was involved in a discussion on 
it six months ago...)...I have noticed a problem with this current theory...

We seem to be associating the bully we see in the memory as Mr. 
Snape...Severus Snape's stepfather.  In the book, this ugly character is described as 
having a hook nose.  While Snape is surely not the only one with a hook nose, we 
are told often enough he has one...enough times to assume that this is Snape's 
NATURAL father...so perhaps this is Mr. Black...or maybe Snape's mother was a 
Black herself.......

Just a thought....

Amberlyn


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]