The Scar , Runes, and Theories of GH events. WAS ( His mothers eyes)

[mooseming]

No: HPFGUIDX 122280


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "M.Clifford" <Aisbelmon at h...> 
wrote:
> 
> Vmonte wrote:
> > > What if the dementors are actually the left over 
> remnants/discarded soulless shells of the people that the evil 
> entity has used throughout time. (Could it be SS?)
> > > 
> > > vmonte
> > 
> > ...or what if dementors are the shells of people who have passed 
> > through the veil????
> > 
> > Regards
> > Jo
> > 
> > btw see OTChatter for belated mooseming mystery denial/apology
> 
> Valky responds:
> 
> Ahh the famous mooseming returns! Welcome Back! BTW oopsy 
> misattribution up ther that was vmontes idea. but anyway, its 
> intriguing isn't it, how does one become soulless, I wonder. Are 
> dementors born or are they made? 
> 
> Now Barty Crouch Jr didn't become one when he was kissed so that 
> rules out that option. What are we left with? The veil, yes maybe, 
> but I should really hope that's not true, if anyone returns from 
the 
> veil, naturally I want it to *be Sirius* fully restored to his 
> former gorgeous self. 
> And I neither like the possibility that vivian brought up of Harry 
> being kissed to rid his soul of Voldemort, oooh no, please no.
> 
> Whether Dementors are born or made, they are simply too vile for 
me 
> to want to associate them with Harry's destiny or Sirius' destiny. 
> Oh let them be reunited in death if need be just NOT THAT!
> 
> Valky :D

ah but the romance of that story, can you resist?

Harry can't bring Sirius back (JKR has said so) but he could save 
Sirius' soul and his mortal remains from the old 'fate worse than 
death'. At the same time Harry could learn that there are 'worse 
things than death', come to terms with his parents fate and reject 
immortality, defeat voldy by loving enough to let go....

JKR also said she *had* to kill Sirius, perhaps because he has a job 
to do which requires him to be dead.....

Say hello to Sirius the undead!

Jo