No: HPFGUIDX 122400 Juli wrote: ...how come it is Quirell who dies at the end and DD and Hagrid tell Harry that Snape is the good guy. I don't believe Snape is evil or helping Voldemort in any way. vmonte responds: I know. I even said this in my post. I was just trying to read the events in another way. I admit the story doesn't flow right if Snape is the bad guy in SS/PS.