Pensieve memories again. Was: Harry's anger

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 122417


Alla earlier:

snip.

But yes, I do think that Harry should have been allowed the option 
to  hide some of his potentially embarrasing moments in the 
Pensieve. If  nothing else, it would made him trust Snape more... 
maybe. He would  have seen that Snape is not "out to get him" (as I 
pretty much feel  he was), but "out to teach him" and that they are 
indeed on the same  side.
 
Potioncat:
In an earlier discussion about the Pensieve, I think we came to the 
conclusion that this is indeed, DD's Pensieve.  If there is only 
one, I doubt that it can be shared.  And I would think Snape's need 
outweighed Harry's.


Alla:

Do you mind if I disagree with such conclusion?  :o)

Not even that it is DD's Pensieve,it may very well be,  but that 
there is only one of those in whole WW.

I for some reason doubt it, but I can be wrong of course.

So, Harry could be given his own, OR if it is expensieve, Harry can 
be told to buy his own, since he is not poor.

I am pretty sure he would have made this purchase very willingly.

JMO,

Alla