I Hate Ginny Weasley!!!!

xcpublishing xcpublishing at yahoo.com
Thu Jan 20 17:52:21 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122501


Hickengruendler writes:

>And I also know that she's at an age where people change, but 
>still I, too, found her change to sudden, and was for example 
>dissatisfied with Jo's explanation about Ginny's Quidditch skills. 
>It's really impossible, that she's flying secretly around the 
Burrow, 
>without anyone noticing.

I thought the "secret" quidditch skills to be somewhat ludicrous.  
Why on earth would she need to be sneaky about it?  Her family is 
full of quidditch fanatics so I can't understand why they wouldn't 
encourage a talent for it, especially when her brothers already have 
skill.  As the only girl, she might be a trifle overprotected, but it 
doesn't seem logical that she could practice unseen with so many 
siblings.  And how much more dangerous is quidditch than 
spellcasting?  Not much.  If she's good at quidditch, make her good 
from the get-go instead of introducing it later as something of a 
surprise.

Nicky Joe







More information about the HPforGrownups archive