Half Blood Prince Theory

[Tonks]

No: HPFGUIDX 122512


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Stephanie" <glowriter at c...> 
wrote:
> 
> Stephanie:
> Hi,
> I'm new here. (Snip)>I have an idea that Trevor the toad is the 
HBP. I think JKR has been pointing him out to us as he continually 
escapes from Neville. How he is a Prince I'm not sure, but I 
strongly think he is either a wizard turned into a toad, or an 
animangus. 
-----------------
Tonks here:

Welcome to the group Stephanie!

Trevor as the HBP. Well now it would be just like JKR to do that!  
Right under our noses all along. Last thing most of us would think 
of even though it is in all of those fairytales. Does make you 
wonder doesn't it??

If he is under a spell maybe he is really old from the time of 
Neville's grandfather or even later. Who gave Neville that frog, 
wasn't it his grandfather?  And all this time we thought it was 
because the giver was just out of step with what was fashionable. I 
can just hear JKR snickering now... "Ha ha, they never guessed it! 
As blatantly obvious as it was. Yes if you want to hide something 
put it right out there in the open and no one will ever see it. I 
got 'um again!!"

Tonks_op