The Order's means of communication...
jlv230
jlv230 at yahoo.co.uk
Thu Jan 20 21:40:13 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 122513
LisaMarie said:
JKR herself (long may she prosper) states, in the "Rumors" section
of her website, that the Order's means of communication "requires
nothing but a wand," and that we have seen it employed by an Order
member, but before we knew the Order existed.
(link: http://www.jkrowling.com/textonly/rumours_view.cfm?id=26)
I am enclined to agree with Meng Yu, who stated upthread that the
most likely means would be the Patronus (or something that looks
very much like a Patronus), as we see it used in GoF when DD summons
Hagrid to the edge of the Forest when Crouch Sr. appears and Krum is
attacked.
Reason #1 It requires /only/ a wand.
Reason #2 DD is an Order member. (obviously)
Reason #3 We didn't know about the Order at this time, but we were
about to find out about it.
<snip>
Reason #4 It is not vulnerable to interception or trickery
(something else Jo mentions in the above link).
Relatedly, we have seen a Patronus do as it was told: in the 'Dudley
Demented" chapter of OOTP, when Harry's Patronus drives away the
first Dementor, he orders it to turn and drive off the other, too,
and it does. This is the only instance I know of where a Patronus
does as it's told, but maybe we just haven't been fully educated on
the functions of the Patronus yet.
So, what does the rest of the HPfGU world think of this theory?
JLV here:
I definitely agree that the Patronus is the most likely candidate
for being the method of communication that the Order use.
I would like to add that the Patronus has a particular significance
for Harry as his Patronus represents his father. Now, I believe one
of the main themes of the books is parents (a subject close to JKRs
heart as we know from interviews/her website) and I think that
Harry's Patronus is highly symbolic of parental protection. (A bit
like Lily's sacrifice, if you will.) I therefore thought it would be
a shame if all these impressive pieces of magic can do is chase
Dementors away (amazing as that may be). All this has led me to
speculate on the role that Patroni (particularly Harry's) are likely
to play in the final battle with Voldemort. I want Prongs to fight
side by side with Harry - wouldn't that be a Kodak moment?
Your opinions/wild suggestions would be welcome!
JLV
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive