Half Blood Prince Theory

[Brenda]

No: HPFGUIDX 122539


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Stephanie" <glowriter at c...> 
wrote:
> 
> Stephanie:
> Hi,
> I'm new here. I love getting on here and reading what you all have 
to
> say. I know for a fact that you are all way ahead of me on the 
subject
> of Harry Potter, but I'm a newbie at having just read the books 
nine
> months ago. I've looked around to see if anyone has asked this yet,
> but I didn't see anything. I was talking to my best friend about HP
> and it dawned on me about a possible suspect for HBP. I mentioned 
it
> as a joke since I can almost not believe it to be true. Well, I 
have
> an idea that Trevor the toad is the HBP. I think JKR has been 
pointing
> him out to us as he continually escapes from Neville. How he is a
> Prince I'm not sure, but I strongly think he is either a wizard 
turned
> into a toad, or an animangus. I'm reading the books again now, so I
> plan on paying more attention to information regarding Trevor. I 
may
> be imagining things.
> 
> My friend is hopeful that he will be a relation to Harry somehow so
> he's not always without family. I don't know about that, but I 
wonder
> if JKR would actually make a toad a prince. If she had someone kiss
> him like Hermione, or Ginny, to bring him back to human form, it 
would
> be even more farfetched. I truly don't think that part will be 
true,
> but I still think Trevor will be the prince. Another thought that
> another friend of mine brought up was that there has already been a
> "pet deceiving the owner" routine with Ron and Scabbers, so I 
could be
> grasping here. 
> 
> Thanks for letting me post my little farfetched theory. I hope this
> hasn't been asked a million times. I just wanted to see what all of
> you thought about it.

Luckdragon:
Well this theory is just as good as any others and there is one 
little quote from Jo in a past interview that has always niggled at 
me.
insert:
What happened to Neville's Toad?
JKR: He's still lurking..
Curious! Very curious!