Sirius Mother's Picture / Kreacher

bleckybecs bleckybecs at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 21 04:01:43 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122578


> Becky:
> > I had assumed that all OOTP meetings would take place in the 
> > kitchen, out of hearing of portraits. <snip>
> 
> Tonks here:
> Well now that sounds good. Except what about Kreacher?  Wouldn't 
> he be around or listening at the door?  He could not leave the 
> house, but he could talk to the portrait. DD is very smart so this
> must have been taken into account. Maybe we just haven't been told.
> I hope that they did something to prevent Mrs. Black from going to 
> the Malfoys.


Hmmm.... there is something in the long talk at the end of OOTP 
where I think that the Krecher buisness is explained (pg. 732 in my 
copy, which is English). DD says that he was directly ordered not to 
give away any of the order's secret plans (and now I'm back to 
assuming), most probably, not to anyone outside of it. That would 
include Sirius's mother. It's clear that he HAS been to the Malfoy's 
from exactly the same talk, but he is limited in what he could tell 
them.

Becky










More information about the HPforGrownups archive