ESE!Pigwidgeon?

[Constance Vigilance]

No: HPFGUIDX 122717


--- hickengruendler wrote:

> 
> First, let me say that this is the most entertaining and surprising 
> theory I read for months.

Thank you. :)

 I enjoyed reading your post, but I want to 
> point out that there is one big difference between Scabbers and Pig. 
> Crookshanks approved of him. In the last chapter Ron gave the owl to 
> Crookshanks for a "sniffling test", and Pigwidgeon passed. ;-)

I'm glad you reminded me. I had intended to mention that.

When Ron passes Pig to Crookshanks for the sniff test, he asks,

What do you think? Is it an owl or not? (not a direct quote because I
don't have my book.)

Crookshanks has no doubt that Pig is an owl. (And neither do I) His
problem with Scabbers was that he wasn't a rat. But Pig is truly an
owl and thus passes the sniff test.

I still think that we should be suspicious of little Pigwidgeon.

~Constance Vigilance