Innocent Albus? (was RE: Why should Harry...)

[naamagatus]

No: HPFGUIDX 122777


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "lupinlore" <bob.oliver at c...> 
wrote:
> 

> Interestingly enough, I agree that there are scenarios where Albus 
>can come out (mostly) innocent and sympathetic, although I personally
> doubt JKR will go with them. I really think she is so deeply 
>invested in her own authorial scheme of the characters and events 
>that she is genuinely mystified why people don't see them the same 
>way she does.

<snip>

>. Likewise when JKR speaks of DD she is
> speaking about the "epitome of goodness" that exists in her mind, 
>NOT about the figure that exists in her books, for whom the 
>title "epitome of goodness" often seems rather inappropriate. 

Umm.. I've reread these paragraphs and I can't make sense of them: 
you say that "there are scenarios where Albus can come out (mostly) 
innocent and sympathetic" but that you "doubt JKR will go with them". 
And yet that in JKR's mind DD is the epitome of goodness. So - why 
wouldn't JKR go with an innocent and sympathetic DD? 

I'm sure I'm completely missing your meaning here. Could you clarify?

Naama