Why should Harry be expected to listen to anyone at, H...

[Amanda Geist]

No: HPFGUIDX 122806


> "Amanda Geist" <editor at t...> wrote:
> 
> > Umbridge did not try to kill Harry.
> > She was going to Crucio him. 

Eggplant:
> Umbridge set the Dementors onto Harry.

Yes, she did, but as I clarified in another post, you were 
specifically referring to attempts by Harry's *teachers.* At the time 
Umbridge set the dementors on Harry, she was in no way a teacher of 
anyone; she was a MoM official.

During her tenure as Harry's *teacher,* she did unspeakably sadistic 
things to him, but did not attempt to kill him.

> Actually I could have 
> included Lupin in my list of homicidal teachers and made it five 
but 
> I just couldn't bring myself to compare him to a toad like 
Umbridge. 

Actually, except for the fact that Werewolf!Lupin was in the forest 
at the same time as Harry, Harry was in no danger from Lupin at any 
point that I can remember. There was no confrontation. I might be 
wrong, please correct me and provide a canon reference.

~Amanda