Who overheard the prophecy? (was Re: Why should Harry be expected to listen to anyone at Hogwarts? / prophecy)

ladymlb777 ladymlb777 at yahoo.com
Sun Jan 23 22:33:49 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 122873


Steph:
> Also, who is the spy that overheard the prophecy being told in 
> the Hog's Head?

Whoever it was that overheard the prophecy didn't hear the entire 
thing. So no one outside of DD and Harry would know the part that 
one has to die for the other to live. 

Chancie:
> One of the most suspected characters would probably be Snape. 
> But since there's no cannon implicating anyone, other than that 
> it was someone who was working for Voldemort, we don't know.

I actually don't think that it was Snape that overheard the prophecy, 
I think that it was Mundungus. I think that it was a little odd that 
he was spying on the DA in Hog's Head, hiding because he had been 
kicked out for something. Which is the same place that the proph was 
overheard; the eavesdropper being thrown out. Just a thought.

"Michele" 







More information about the HPforGrownups archive