Why should Harry be expected to listen to anyone at Hogwarts?

[M.Clifford]

No: HPFGUIDX 122968



> > Tonks writes:
> > 
> > >I totally disagree. A teacher or anyone in a position to be 
one's superior is to be treated with the respect afforded their 
office.
> 

> Julie replies:
> 
> I think there is a difference between having or feeling respect 
for someone and *treating* someone with respect. Harry doesn't have
> to feel respect for Snape to treat him with the respect due his 
station.


Valky:
You know, IMHO this thread is just too hard on Harry.  Frankly, 
Harry respects Severus a great deal more than Draco ever will.
And I agree with Nicky Joe, Lupinlore, SSSusan and Alla and others 
who point out that he has much less reason to. Student/Teacher 
relationship or not, Sevvie gets more respect than he deserves from 
Harry.

And BTW I like Alla would like to see them come to blows in a feisty 
melee, I don't think that will be stooping on Harry's behalf, it 
will be an experience for them both.