Snape & Harry working to control Voldy's mind? (was: DD's serious errors)
dumbledore11214
dumbledore11214 at yahoo.com
Tue Jan 25 19:32:11 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 123019
Alla:
Interesting . Are you thinking about Neri's theory that Snape still
has mind-link with Voldie or are you thinking about something else?
If you are thinking about another Occlumency attempt, I personally
doubt it. I think if Snape will be teaching Harry ANYTHING, it will
occur because of extraordinary circumstances, not just regular
reasons.
SSSusan again:
Well, actually I was thinking of a point, late in Year 6 or even into
Year 7. A point at which Harry & Snape have finally managed that
shaky truce and are prepared to at least grudgingly trust that the
other *is* working for the same End (even if he is still an impudent,
arrogant brat/*professor*prick).
Yes, I was thinking along the lines of Occlumency -- or something
new, proposed, perhaps a never-before-investigated-last-ditch-effort
variation of Occlumency. ReverseOcclumencyViaScarlink or something?
I hadn't even thought to ask how this might fit w/ Neri's VASSAL
theory [je regret, Neri], but now that you mention it, yes, that
could be a part of why SNAPE, rather than DD or someone else.
Thoughts, Neri?
Alla:
Before we hear from Neri, couple more thoughts from me. :o) Yes, I
absolutely agree that middle of year 7, NOT year 6 is more realistic
point of having those interactions, if ever.
I also think that before that someone will take the issue of Harry's
training more seriously and will give him Occlumency lessons or
whatever else he needs. Hopefully, it will be Dumbledore.
I think that something draumatic will preceed interactions with
Snape, something Bangy! if you will, I just don't see them gradually
overcoming the hostilities.
JMO,
Alla
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive