Harry's Seclusion and the Weasley Suspicion
Jay
coatiman2020 at yahoo.com
Fri Jan 28 20:05:34 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 123338
This may be just my own Hufflepuff paranoia, but I have a strong
feeling that Harry's seclusion into the comfort of Gryffindor and the
Weasly boy's suspicion and immediate distaste of anyone better than
them may come back and bite them on the butt later on.
It seems, and I don't have my books with me so I can't cite canon,
that Harry has very little, if any idea of who his other classmates
are. Now that he has the DA, that may change, but how many times have
we heard mention of "somone Harry knew only by face" or not knowing
anyone other than gryffindors at all. If it weren't for mixed house
classes and the occasional Quidditch match, would Harry know his
other classmates at all?
My next problem is with the Weasleys. Now the parent's seems nice
enough, I'd certainly love to get to know Arthur and Molly. The older
siblings seem very open to meeting new people as well. We know since
Charlie works with dragons outdoors, he must meet all kinds of
people. The same goes for Bill working as a treasure hunter. But what
about the twins and Ron? Justin Finch-Fletchley innocently mentions
that he likes Lockhart and is immediately dubbed an idiot by Ron
(again, I forget the exact words). He was simply stating that he
liked an energetic, albeit bumbling and stupid, teacher. Ron unjustly
jumped to conclusions just because his ideas didn't mesh with
Justin's.
As soon as Cedric Diggory beats the Gryffindors at Quidditch he's an
idiot/ "pretty boy" to Fred and George, probably Ron too. Did
jealousy play a part? Maybe it's just my psychology classes finally
taking root, but as soon as Oliver Wood mentions Cedric's name, the
three female chasers burst into giggles. Maybe there's some feeling
of inadequacy on the twin's part when they're up against Cedric. They
seem comfortable enough around girls, so perhaps the immediate
distate is something deeper.
As a Hufflepuff, I'll be the first to admit that I'm sure Zacharias
Smith can get on your nerves. He would get on mine if I had to share
a dorm with him. But that still doesn't justify Fred and George
wanting to molest him with pointy objects as soon as he voices his
opinion about Harry and Voldemort. They don't seem able to think
outside their own comfort zones. In fourth year one of his
(Zacharias's) housemates, was found dead. All they knew was that
Harry came out of the maze carrying Cedric's body. Harry was the only
one who really knew what went on, and let's face it, all the evidence
seemed to point that Harry did something. While he may have come off
a bit strong, Zacharias had every right to be suspiscious. It's about
time a Hufflepuff finally stands up to a Gryffindor.
I know I've been rambling on some very strange issues, but that
always irked me about the books. Thanks for letting me rant and it'll
be interesting to hear what you all have to say.
-Jay-
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive