I'd like feedback on this theory (Mundungus)

[raesstienway]

No: HPFGUIDX 123592



Rachel writes:
Interesting theory, I could see this going both ways, Mundungus 
could betray the OotP as mentioned or he could stay loyal. . Really 
this does depend on why he is loyal to Dumbeldore and if this 
loyalty will hold, as mentioned by Cindi.
Cindi writes:
> I think Mundungus could betray the Order for the write price, but 
again why is he so loyal to Dumbledore and will the strength of that 
loyalty hold? Here is my thought: 

Rachel Writes:
Has Dumbeldore ever helped anyone out of a scrape that did not 
invoke complete loyalty? Look at his whole staff, even crazy 
Trelwany is loyal, so would he really help this "good" thief and 
have no issues with him being in the Order if this was ever to be a 
problem. Seems to me that none of the order members have all their 
eggs in one basket and that after last time they are sure to be very 
shrewd. So, yes it very well could be Mundungus, but my suspision is 
that even if it is him they will discover him early on and kick him 
out, or even more likely not reveal that they know and feed him 
false info that will then be passed to V. But then again, JKR is 
writing this not me so we will have to wait and see.....
Rachel
> 
>