[HPforGrownups] Re: Christmas present pattern...

[ewe2]

No: HPFGUIDX 131819

On Fri, Jul 01, 2005 at 01:44:17PM -0000, lupinlore wrote:

This is a logically false premise and unsubstantiated by canon.

Statement A

> Hermione is not some martyr to a pair of lazy boys.

Statement B

> She is a tightly integrated part of the trio who has chosen her own role and
> relishes it.  Sometimes she relishes it far too much, as in many places in
> OOTP where she badly needs a smack in the mouth.  

Statement C

> The homework planner was one of them.  

Put together, Statement A and C are logically incompatible. If your meaning
was that Hermione does not need to assist the boys, how is giving them that
independence with a planner offensive? If your meaning is that Hermione enjoys
assisting the boys, why would she reduce her role with a planner?

You cannot prove Statement B but you use it as a bizarre justification for
gratuitous violence and make an illogical link between Statements A and C.
There is no canon for Statements A,B, or C.

Q.E.D.

ewe2, penguin of doom and professor of irrelevant posts 101.

-- 
sed awk grep cat dd ..Im a luser baby ,so why don't you killall -kill me.