What is it with the Bones's?

potioncat willsonkmom at msn.com
Tue Jul 5 10:56:54 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 131990

Jim wrote: 
> I say movie contamination on account of Susan. Her name was speculated
> on because of her unduly common appearance in the first two movies.
> Columbus's daughter, and all that.

Potioncat:
I agree with the movie contamination slant. Susan was all over the 
place in the first movie. But she is Columbus' daughter and more 
telling: she is American. So I would think if there was a canon related 
reason to advance her, JKR would have insisted she be played by a 
British actress. OTOH, Susan is probably one of the more likely choices 
for Harry, out of a long list.

Jim: 
> Sure, Amelia is plausible. I agree, and it's not a stretch. We've just
> exhausted the reasons to suggest her. It may be her, maybe not.
> 

Potioncat:
I don't think Amelia Bones will be the Minister of Magic. JKR 
answered "Unfortunately, no." When asked if Arthur will be the next 
Mininster. To me, that either indicates that something unfortunate is 
going on in Arthur's life; or that the choice for Minister is 
unfortunate. From what we've seen, Amelia would be a good choice.






More information about the HPforGrownups archive