Grindelwald (was Re: MAJOR ... ALCHEMIST THEORY)

[tinglinger]

No: HPFGUIDX 132054

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "karenoc1" <karenoc1 at y...> wrote:
> > aussie
> > -------------
> > At last someone talks of Grindelwald (called "DWG" for Dark Wizard 
> > Grindelwald in the rest of this post).
> > According to the Choc Frog card, DWG was DEFEATED, not "KILLED".
> > Can we say the LV was DEFEATED, not KILLED, when Harry was a baby?
> > 
> > tinglinger
> > --------------
> > hmmmm i like your point. But if defeated was enough why isn't the 
> > defeat of Lord Voldemort mentioned on the card as well?
> 
> now karenoc1
> -----------------
> Small point here, but the defeat of LV would not be mentioned on 
> Dumbledore's card, because he didn't defeat him.  Harry did, yes?

tinglinger
------------------
You are correct --- hmmm I wonder where Harry's frog card is?