Question1 - Godrics Hollow

[esmith222002]

No: HPFGUIDX 132096

What happened at Godric's Hollow is key to the whole series. We know 
that much from JKR herself. The way the books are written, this means 
for us to find out, someone has to tell us. But who?

1. Dumbledore - Everything so far indicates that DD really is not 
exactly sure what happened at Godric's hollow, and why it is that 
Voldemort failed. Surely it has to be someone who was actually there. 
So who was there??

2. Voldemort - LV could tell Harry what happened, or Harry could even 
get into LVs head and see for himself. PROBLEM - LV doesn't seem to 
know what happened or why would he be searching for the prophecy

3. Severus Snape?? - We don't know if he was there or not. But he 
knew all the Death Eater's secrets + all the Orders secrets, so is in 
a unique position to understand the events at Godric's Hollow. 
PROBLEM - If he know's why hasn't he told DD??

4. Lily (Sirius' mirror) - IS the whole reason for Sirius' death, so 
that he can track down Lily's spirit, and then relay what happened to 
Harry via the mirror. Definitely my favourite!!!!!!!!

Brothergib