Who will tell Harry what happened? (WAS:Re: Question1 - Godrics Hollow)

esmith222002 c.john at imperial.ac.uk
Fri Jul 8 09:03:59 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 132256

I hadn't even considered Lupin. Good Canon for his involvement as well. 
Although I cannot think of a logical reason why he would have been at 
Godric's Hollow and survived. I don't agree with the ESE theory. Lupin 
appears (even from the evidence of his days at Hogwarts) to possess the 
utmost honour and integrity. So if he knows, I think it is his 
involvement in the Order that has given him this knowledge. More 
questions?
Does everyone in the order know?
If so, why is it so important to not let Harry know the whole truth?

And i'll ask the question again - why didn't DD let Harry hear the 
whole prophecy?

Brothergib (my other theory involved the time-turner - but if 3 clicks 
takes you back a few hours, how many do you need to go back 18 years??)






More information about the HPforGrownups archive