Relationships
rolshan2000
rolshan2000 at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 8 18:04:02 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 132288
davenclaw wrote:
> I've never been much of a "shipper," but I'll throw in my two cents.
>
> I think that JKR will keep things relatively straightforward and
> simple. We can interpret what we want from the interactions of the
I agree with all your analysis davenclaw. Any storyline other than
a "simple" extension of what has been heavily hinted before - R/H and
H/G, would require a great deal of development. With only two books
left (and one of these shorter than OOP) and with the war to
conclude, Voldemort to defeat and a myriad questions/puzzles to be
resolved, it is highly unlikely that JKK would spend the time
necessary to, for example, develop and then resolve a romantic
triangle among the trio.
Further, R/H is even more definitively foreshadowed in the moooovies,
and although I know the cry "they just do whatever they want in
those, nothing to do with canon", I do not for a moment believe that
JKK would have permitted the storyline to become so committed to R/H
if she knows that this would have to be reversed in the remainder of
the series.
Finally, and to me most convincingly, I do not believe romance will
be a major focus of the remaining two books - at most a "light"
sidestory. If that is the case, only the already set up ships R/H
and H/G would be able to be played this way -- any other alternative
would require complexity, exposition and/or unexpected revelations.
Rolshan
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive