[HPforGrownups] Lupin = James: STAGgering New Evidence

[Sherry Gomes]

No: HPFGUIDX 132382

I think I may be one of the few serious readers of the septology 
that still clings to Galadriel Waters' theory that Remus Lupin is 
actually James Potter. I do not believe the switch was made as a 
kind of sacrifice; instead it is the after affect of a switching 
spell plan by Lilly that occurred just before LV's attack and went 
terribly wrong (it was never Lilly's intent that Lupin-as-James 
would die so that James-as-Lupin could live).


Sherry now:

I can't find the exact reference on her web site, but JKR answered this
theory by saying it was a great theory but not true.  It's either in the
rumors or FAQ section of her site.

sherry