Is there really such a thing as Disapparating?

finwitch finwitch at yahoo.com
Fri Jul 15 19:19:06 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 132892

 "davenclaw"  wrote:
> I'm beginning to wonder about the nature of Apparating.  
> Specifically, do people instantly appear in the new location after 
> disappearing from the previous location, or is there some sort of 
> state of limbo in between?  Because it seems to me that unless 
there 
> is a state of limbo, there is really no distinction between 
> apparating and disapparating - they are essentially the exact same 
> thing, but from different perspectives (whether you are referring 
to 
> where they are leaving or where they are arriving).--
> 
>   But the way that JKR refers to them, it is as if they are really 
> two separate events..

Finwitch:

I think they ARE one and same, and only perspective changes. They 
seem to be different when Hermione says things like you can't 
apparate or disapparate in Hogwarts... meaning that both directions  
are prevented.

There could be shields that permit apparating a place, but not 
disapparating (like a fish-trap), possibly even some that prevent 
apparating but not disapparating. (useful if you need a place where 
none can suddenly enter, but you can LEAVE quickly - if you have need 
to see who's coming but don't care who's leaving...). Of course, most 
places have neither.

Finwitch






More information about the HPforGrownups archive