Super Early Predictions for book 7

[templar1112002]

No: HPFGUIDX 132943

vmonte wrote:
> > 5. Snape has been working for a long time to destroy LV and DD
> > 6. Trelawny's prophecies are a hoax perpetrated by Snape to keep
> > LV and DD distracted while he slowly destroys both camps.
> 
> Brothergib responded:
> You forget that Trelawney's prophecy was made to Dumbledore! Snape has
> carried out Dumbledore's orders and will help Harry in the end. I 
don't
> think Snape agrees with Dumbledore that Harry can finish Voldemort, 
but
> he has given his word, so has to carry it out!
> 
> vmonte answered back:
> The prophecy was made to Dumbledore but Snape was also there. Was he 
> really listening or controlling Trelawny?
> 
***Marcela now:  But how do you explain the second prophecy?  The one 
in PoA, only Harry and Trelawny were there...

Marcela