SHIP: Pirate Ginny

mg_mchenry mg_mchenry at hotmail.com
Tue Jul 19 16:17:11 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 133035

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Pat" <5682574 at s...> wrote:
> The trio's out of character behavior was the thing that turned me 
> off the most in HBP. Now I think I see what that's all about, and 
> I've stopped hating this book and Jo.
> 
> Love potions seem to be a thread in this book. 
...
> She can bold face lie to Molly. She has the 
> guts to ram a commentator at a Quidditch match.
...
> Another 
> person pointed out that Hermione being obsessed from Love Potion 
> could explain her lack of SPEW comments. I expected a speech to 
> Harry about Kreacher at the least.
> 
> I think Molly's favorite Christmas song is a clue about this. It's 
> called "A Caldron Full of Hot, Stong Love". 

Brilliant.  You've made my day.  I was so frustrated by their behavior
- I knew it didn't really add up.

So many clues must add up to something.

But, I think you have to consider that Ginny really is a plausable
mate for Harry.  Harry needs Hermione in his fight more than he needs
Ginny, but Ginny is so much more *like* Harry.  Also, he's never shown
any romantic interest in Hermione.

As difficult as it is for me to get my head around the R/H pairing,
Hermione's actions toward Ron were persistent, crafty, and patient. 
Those are much more Hermione's trademarks than the effects of a love
potion.  Ron's feelings were telgraphed well in advance.

 --mg_mchenry







More information about the HPforGrownups archive