Odd thought re McGonagall & other random replies & questions

[kljohnson7868]

No: HPFGUIDX 133100

Why do you suppose that Harry chose not to reveal any part of the 
plan to Minerva at the end of HBP? He was told to trust his friends 
because they'd earned it, so Hermione & Ron would be in on the 
details. But why not Minerva?

Snape: I think he's a good guy. I will only be repeating what others 
have said better and more often, so I'll leave it at that. I don't 
think he's changed back over to the DE camp.

Harry, to live or die: I do believe that his scar is a horcrux. Will 
Harry live to the end of the series? I don't know. I see irony in 
the nickname, "The Boy Who Lived" because he may well end up being 
the man who died. He may well sacrifice himself (because of love, 
the powerful force which LV has not) so that others will live. 

RAB: I like the idea that it is NOT Regulus Black, but rather 
someone else - Borgin from the shop. JKR already has a history of 
making us think one thing, but then heading us down a different path.

Question: I still don't get what the significance is of Lily's eyes 
and her talent with charms. Nothing seemed to be mentioned in HBP, 
so I'm still confused as to why this is so, so important. Ideas?

DD's death: It had to happen. I'd like to know more about the 
potions (Slugworth? Snape?) that he drank in the cave. 

So many unanswered questions.....

Kathi