Thoughts on HBP

meriaugust meriaugust at yahoo.com
Tue Jul 19 20:17:10 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 133138

Just had to join in on the fun. 

Harry - I was incredibly surprised (in a good way) how much more 
mature and grownup he acted in this book. Other than the quick 
mention of him not eating back at the Dursleys, he seems to have 
dealt with Sirius' death quite well. I was also impressed about how 
he is dealing with the prophecy, taking on responsibility for 
defeating LV and accepting this as his destiny instead of running 
away or resenting it; making it his choice (he really is DD's man). 
For 16 he's become quite mature and I hope this is an indication 
that he's really starting to become an adult. As for his 
relationship with Ginny, all I have to say is, "Yippee!" I loved so 
much the passages where he tries to justify his feelings for her as 
older brother-ish and when he wanted to beat the crap out of Dean 
for kissing her in the halls. I was a mite disappointed that he 
decided to break up with her in the end, but he's right: this is 
something that he has to do by himself, it is his destiny and no one 
else's, and while Ginny would have every right to be ticked that 
he's making decisions for her, I was also impressed by her own 
maturity in that situation, accepting his choice and holding out 
hope for the future (please, let there be one!). And that bit about 
Harry's Hungarian Horntail tattoo? Priceless. 

Ron/Hermione - Vindication! I loved their bickering (as I always 
did) and loved the complexities that were worked into their 
relationship. I was also qutie pleased that they both decided to 
help Harry next year, whether he returns to Hogwarts or not. My mom 
says that's just setting them up to die, but I disagree: these two, 
I'm sure, will make it through unscathed. 

And to get the rest of the shipping out of the way: 
Fleur/Bill - Oh, gag me. 
Remus/Tonks - Oh, so cute. It's about time he had a friend who 
wasn't evil or dead. Do we have a consensus on her age? I always 
thought she was in her early twenties, and if Remus is now 37-38, 
that's not too old. 

Dumbledore - Well, let's just say we saw this one coming from Day 1. 
I am of the opinion that he will be back in some form, as Harry 
still has a good bit of quest to be getting on with and he'll need 
the help. What I really want to know is where Fawkes got to and how 
DD's portrait got into the Head's office so quickly. But on a more 
serious note, those last four chapters were some of the most gut-
wrenching of the series (up there with Cedric's murder, LV's 
rebirth, the Shreiking Shack, and the DoM battle), but how 
touched/moved was I when DD finally revealed the depth of his love 
for Harry? When Harry fixed DD's glasses? Oh, brother, bring on the 
tears. 

Snape - Taking an Unbreakable Vow? Is he brain dead? Or was this all 
part of the plan? DD didn't fear death, we know that, so maybe there 
is some higher reasoning behind this (something I'm sure we'll all 
speculate to death over the next thousand days!). But Snape, the 
Half-Blood Prince? Didn't see that one coming. He must have been a 
truly brilliant student to have created that book while still at 
school. And I was a bit disappointed that we didn't get to see him 
teach DADA more, something that Harry would clearly have been able 
to show him up at. 

R.A.B. - Regulus Black. Enough said. 

The Dursleys - I really hope we get some closure with them in the 
next book. I still want to know what Dudley saw when he got 
demented. And I am fully curious about the nature of Lily and 
Petunia's relationship. 

Horcruxes - Nagini, Slytherin Locket, Hufflepuff Cup, Ravenclaw 
item, Ring, Diary, LV himself. I can't wait to find out what of 
Ravenclaw's there might still be left (I think DD was probably right 
about the sword being all that there was left of Godric). The 
locket, I think we are mostly in agreement, is somewhere in 
Grimmauld Place (good thing Harry inherited it). I don't buy the 
theory that Harry is an unintentional horcrux; I think that LV had 
already gotten seven of them when he went after the Potters, which 
is why he felt confident enough to go up against them that night. 
Besides, with all DD confided in him, if he had even thought this 
was a possibility he probably would have told Harry.  

Peverelle Family? - Also related to the Gaunts, part of LV's 
ancestry. Who are they? Who else draws a bloodline from them? Their 
ring has been destroyed, but is there anything else left of them? 

Family homes - Harry wants to go to Godric's Hollow, see his 
parents' house and their graves, about darn time, if you ask me. I 
think he'll also be paying visits to the Riddle House and the Gaunt 
house during the course of his search for the remaining four 
horcruxes. And speaking of Gaunts and Riddles...

Young Tom Riddle - Those were some of the most amazing scenes JKR 
has written, IMVHO. The one at the orphanage gave me the shudders 
(with the strangled rabbit and all...ooooh...creepy), and to think 
about LV crossing Hogwarts' threshold with DD's permission, 
terrifying. LV doesn't seem like such a cardboard bad guy anymore, 
and the insights into his character are telling (I especially liked 
the line where DD asks if Harry is feeling sorry for LV, something 
that Harry vehemently denies, but which I think might be true 
anyway) and I can see his progression quite clearly now. And I can 
also imagine his shock when, after building up in his imagination a 
father who was a powerful and strong wizard, discovered that it was 
his weak mother, the one who abandoned him to life at the orphanage, 
who gave him his powers. And then to discover that his father was 
alive and well but had never sought him out, and that his mother's 
family was old and pure-blooded and stretched back to Slytherin 
himself? Now the ideology he espouses is a little clearer. DD's 
description of LV, as someone who prefers to be alone, superior and 
in charge, strikes right at the difference between him and Harry: 
though Harry needs his alone time (and don't we all), and though he 
will have to complete this task by himself (as he has before) it 
takes the help of his friends to get him through everything, 
something LV will never understand. 

Lupin's backstory - I was quite pleased to get some insight into 
this character, who is one of my faves. His history with Fenrir 
Greyback and his secret mission make me wonder how this book will 
sit with the ESE!Lupin postulators. 

Neville - Where were you, brave Longbottom boy? Hardly mentioned 
until we find out that he was one of the two ex-DA members to come 
to Hogwarts' aid during the last battle. Neville is finally coming 
out of his father and his grandmother's shadows, and I would kill to 
read the letter McGonagall sent to Augusta about him. 

Funniest bits - Arthur and Molly's safety questions for entry into 
the Burrow. Fred and George's joke shop. Harry and Luna at the Slug 
Party (well, there's our vampire). "Won-won!" The canaries. Dobby 
still unable to keep from punishing himself. Harry remembering 
Dumbledore as he really was ("Nitwit, blubber, oddiment, tweak!"). 
All classics. 

Meri - how soon till the next one?  






More information about the HPforGrownups archive