[HPforGrownups] Re: Tonks in HBP ( spoilers of course!)

[Katherine Coble]

No: HPFGUIDX 133274


On Jul 19, 2005, at 9:29 AM, anthyroserain wrote:

> "kjirstem" <stonehenge.orders at v...> wrote:
>  > I may be entirely too
>  > suspicious, but for much of the book I was convinced that Tonks was
>  > someone else on Polyjuice...
>
>  A decidedly bizarre thought: what if Tonks were in fact Pettigrew? He
>  has little to do in HBP, and her mousy appearance is mentioned
>  *several* times.
>
>  No, I don't actually believe this is the case, but it seemed an
>  interesting idea.
>
>
Katherine now:

I really think that the only thing wrong with Tonks was unrequited 
love.  She thanks Molly for "the tea and sympathy" back at the Burrow; 
Molly and Arthur quickly change the subject when they think that Harry 
will reveal the new Patronus conjured by Tonks.

Basically, Harry is wrapped up in his own universe and doesn't bother 
to make himself aware of the drama between Tonks and Lupin.  I don't 
think any convoluted polyjuice drinking plays into it at all.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]