[HPforGrownups] Re: SHIP: Pirate Ginny

[joj]

No: HPFGUIDX 133313



  Chancie wrote:
  Perhaps one BIG fact that you seem to have over looked, is that
  we've seen how Love Potion effects people.  Look at Ron's obsession
  with Romalda Vane.  He was crazed, and could not help himself.

  Joj writes: 
  Yes, but remember, we know that this was an old potion and therefore too strong.  Why do this, and not show us Ron having a normal reaction?  So we don't recognize the real reaction?

  Sienna wrote:
  Otherwise, I would have to accept that Rowling has lost her touch and 
  was unable to deliver realistic romantic scenarios (even if they did 
  have to involve Harry/ Ginny). I think Rowling might have been having 
  a go at ALL the ships in this one actually and if this is right, then 
  she is capable of a subtlety that I cannot help but admire.

  Joj writes:
  If this theory were true though, we'd have to believe that Jo would be writing character's OOC and have people critisizing her writing for at least two years.  Would she be willing to do this, to pull off what she wants in book 7?  I think she would.

  Joj, who's H/H heart was crushed and doesn't know if she has the heart to believe this theory.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]