Where are the Horcruxes?
leavingedenbehind
leavingedenbehind at yahoo.ca
Wed Jul 20 02:38:51 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 133324
<snip>
> I had another thought about the Horcruxes. There are a couple other
> things at number 12 Grimauld place. When they are cleaning the drawing
> room one of the things they find in the curio cabinet is a music box
> that makes them all sleepy (sorry don't have book in front of me for
> exact page) but it says something like "until Ginny had the good sense
> to close it" another thing in that cabinet was a vile of something
> that looked like blood. so maybe these are things that should have a
> closer look taken of them.
> Sherry
Maybe, but IMO they could just be...stuff. I mean, we have countless examples of things
that are just red herrings in the books. Mark Evans, for one, who made quite a splash.
There are millions of portraits (slight exagerration) in Dumbledore's office who whe've
never heard from, and never will, and there still is the persisting argument for the two
mystery girls in Hermione's dormitory (please excuse if any of this is out of date - have
been living under rock, discussion-wise). Now, I realize that my examples are people
instead of things, and that both the Hand of Glory and deadly necklace from earlier in the
series in Borgin and Burke's made rather impressive cameos this time 'round, but even JKR,
queen of integration, can't fit /everything/ in...
just my 2 cents..
Amanda
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive