How would Voldemort find out?
rosered2318
rosered2318 at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 20 03:28:29 UTC 2005
No: HPFGUIDX 133346
"I'm sorry Harry, I should have said that Voldemort would not want
to immediately kill the person who reached this island. He would
want to keep them alive long enough to find out how they managed to
penetrate so far through his defenses and, most importantly of all,
why they were so intent upon emptying the basin. Do not forget that
Lord Voldemort believes that he, alone, knows about his Horcruxs." (HBP, Ch 26, Scholastic p569)
This quote strikes me. After the second read-thru of HBP, my
secondary reaction was "How would Voldemort find out about the
intruders and their purpose?" As Voldemort did not show up to AK
Harry and DD as they were emptying the basin, I am assuming there
was not a magical alarm associated with entering the cave or
drinking the potion and if it was associated with the awakening of
the Inferi, that would not allow Voldemort enough time to get to the
cave.
But, as often with JKR's work, the surprise does not come from
the "who" or the "how" but the effect that it has or the
circumstances around which it occurs <coughDD'sdeathcough>.
Some problems I forsee with thinking of this phrase as suspect start
with the ring and end with how Voldemort would be notified of the
intrusion. If Voldemort has set a magical recording device around
this Horcrux, then was there one around the ring? If not, why not?
If so, how would Voldemort know that there was something to see? It
would appear as if there was no "alarm" activated. But this phrase
allows us an insight into Voldemort's mind that makes a little too
much sense for me to just pass it off.
The interesting side note (pun intended) - our mysterious Mr. R.A.B
(whom I am assuming is Regulus Black) still has his note in the
basin. This means that Voldy found out about his treachery some
other way and did not bother to retrieve the phony or perhaps left
it there out of spite for the next in line. Perhaps he has placed
the real locket somewhere else or it was destroyed. Another
incidental side note - Regulus must have been killed by Voldy
personally if DD was correct about Voldy not wanting anyone else to
know about the Horcruxs' (even Lucius didn't know about the Diary's
true purpose until afterwards)
Based on DD's quote, I am going to assume that Voldemort knows Harry
is now looking for his Horcrux. The question I now ask is how is
this going to affect Harry's ability to find and destroy them.
Rose
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive