21 Reasons Why Snape is a Good Guy--Let "Desperate Hope" Reign!

abha_j abha_j at yahoo.com
Wed Jul 20 04:42:41 UTC 2005


No: HPFGUIDX 133366


Good point Carolyn!

There are so many posts going on about how Snape should still be 
trusted. I disagree. There is nothing worse than AK, and the act of 
taking somebody's life, and Snape has clearly shown where his loyalty 
lies. I can not believe that so many people are still rooting for him.

I think JK Rowling is not playing any games this time, and is telling 
us the truth, when Snape tells Bellatrix and Narcissa his reasons for 
sticking to DD and not killing Harry all these years.

I think DD had to go in this book, so that Harry can really come into 
his own in the final book. The final book will be about the courage and 
wisdom of Harry Potter & his friends, the coming of age of the boy who 
has been more lucky than smart so far. So far, it was Dumbeldore that 
everybody looked up to, no more so.

In HBP, Harry is already a lot more mature and less impulsive than he 
was a year back. Also, he has now seen that anybody can make mistakes 
in judgement, even DD. He has also learnt to trust his own instincts, 
e.g. regarding Snape.

So the 7th book will not be about the carefully-laid plans of 
Dumbeldore, but will be about Harry and only Harry.
All the best, Harry!
I hate you , Snape. You spoiled the best book in the series for me.
I miss DD!
*sniff*
- Abha









More information about the HPforGrownups archive